Paper Review Criteria

Technical Criteria for Papers that Make a Scientific/Knowledge Contribution

1.Contributions are clearly articulated and sufficient.

2. Objectives are stated and methodology to address objectives is explained.

3. Findings are described and implications discussed.

Technical Criteria for Papers that Make a Practice Contribution

1. Contributions are clearly articulated and sufficient.

2. Clear statement of industry challenge or problem to be addressed or examined.

3. Impact, achieved or anticipated, from described solution or investigation.

Common Editorial Criteria

4. Paper within ESREL 2016 scope

5. Editorial style and presentation is appropriate